Intellectual Disability Rights Service (IDRS)

IDRS Factsheet For Lawyers

Acting for Clients with an intellectual disability

About IDRS

Legal Help

About CJSN

Priority Issues

Education

Information

Useful Contacts

Contact IDRS

Working with a client with an intellectual disability - Factsheet for Lawyers This Factsheet

 

Does my client have an intellectual disability?

An intellectual disability affects the way a person learns. It can affect them in a variety of ways and to different degrees. There are many causes of intellectual disability, including genetic factors, physical injury, illness in childhood, pregnancy or childbirth.

Like everyone else, people with an intellectual disability have a variety of life experiences. Some work in open employment settings; others work in supported employment (previously sheltered workshops) or attend day programs. Some receive Centrelink benefits or other sources of income.

Some live in supported accommodation, such as group homes or residential centres. Others live independently in the community or with family members. Some are in relationships and are parents. Some are aged.

Intellectual disability is not the same as mental illness.

Intellectual disability is sometimes confused with mental illness but they are very different. A mental illness often arises in early adulthood and affects a person's perception and mood. It is often episodic.

Some examples of mental illness are: schizophrenia, depression, bipolar affective disorder (previously manic depression)

An intellectual disability arises either at birth or when the person is a child or young person. It is fairly constant throughout the person's life, although the effect of the disability will depend on what support and opportunities for development the person has.

It impacts on various skill areas such as communication, self-care and social skills.

Depending on the person, a person with a intellectual disability might:

  • take longer to absorb information
  • have difficulty understanding questions, abstract concepts or instructions
  • have difficulty with reading and writing and money skills
  • have a short attention span and might be easily distracted
  • find it difficult to maintain eye contact
  • find it difficult to adapt to new situations or to plan ahead or solve problems
  • find communication over the phone difficult
  • have difficulty expressing their needs

You cannot tell whether a person has an intellectual disability by their appearance. You will need to observe the client for yourself.

If you suspect that your client might have an intellectual disability you could ask them. If they do not know, are not sure, or do not identify as having an intellectual disability you could ask:

  • Did they go to a special school or were they in a special class?
  • Do they receive services from the Department of Ageing, Disability and Home Care (DADHC)?
  • Do they live in a group home or residential centre?
  • Do they have a case or key worker?
  • Do they receive the Disability Support Pension?
  • Do they work in a sheltered workshop?

The answers to these questions may not necessarily indicate intellectual disability.

Working with clients with an intellectual disability

Adjusting your communication style to suit the client can make a difference to the capacity of the client to understand their case, provide instruction and understand and participate in the proceedings.

Be aware that the client may have a short attention span and have difficulty staying on the same subject.

Remember, they may not have absorbed the information you discussed at your last appointment.

  • It is preferable to interview the client in person.
  • Tell the person you want them to let you know if they don't understand
  • Treat the person with respect and build their confidence - don't criticise
  • Allow additional time for the interview
  • Hold the interview in a quite, private area free from distractions and interruptions
  • Allow the person to tell their story - save your questions for the end

Some tips for interviews and speaking on the phone

  • Don't interrupt or finish the person's sentences
  • Use open rather than leading questions
  • Use simple words and sentences - one idea at a time
  • Avoid abstract concepts and don't use jargon. Check whether they understand - get the person to repeat back the information in their own words or ask follow up questions
  • Be aware that the client may need more breaks than other clients
  • You may need to spell out any phone numbers slowly for the client to write down

Hiding their disability

People with an intellectual disability may not want you to know that they have an intellectual disability or wish to hide the effect of their disability from you. This is often because of the stigma associated with having an intellectual disability.

Your client may give a false appearance that they understand what is being said to them. This is referred to as a 'cloak of competence'. The person may be responding in this way to hide that they do not understand or they may be eager to please you and be giving answers they think you want them to give.

This might lead to inappropriate or inconsistent answers to questions. It is important to refrain from using leading questions when speaking with your client.

Allow Time

Allow extra time or more interviews when working with a client with an intellectual disability. Explaining information will take longer and you will need to take more breaks. You may find that you ask a question and the client does not respond within the time period you expect. Avoid jumping in to clarify or ask another question. If you wait you may find that the client's response will come.

Non-verbal communication

Be aware of the client's non-verbal communication and behaviour. This may provide more information about how they are responding to a situation and what they really think about what is happening.

Find out about your client's skill level in reading and writing. Where the client has difficulty reading, make sure you communicate the information contained in any letter to the client in person or on the phone.

When writing to your client consider the following:

  • Use at least 14 or 16 point font
  • Use at least 1.5 spacing
  • Use a clear and easy to read font like Arial
  • Do not make the wording dense
  • Use short sentences and paragraphs
  • Use headings
  • Write in point form
  • Use plain English
  • Include only necessary information in the letter
  • Consider changing any pro forma client agreement to a format that assists the client to understand it.

Reports

Assessments of an intellectual disability are best made by a psychologist. The assessment measures both IQ level and functional skill levels. Both are important. Assessments can suggest an age range within which the person functions, but this information should be used with caution as the person is an adult with their years of experience and they will have strengths and weaknesses in different areas.

If the client has other disabilities such as a mental illness or epilepsy, then an additional assessment by a psychiatrist or neurologist would be useful.

Working with a support person

A client may bring a support person with them to an interview or court appearance. This person might be a CJSN support person, family member, friend, worker or advocate.

You should:

  • Establish what the role of the support person will be. For example, assisting the client to communicate with others, including the solicitor.
  • Talk directly to the client not through the support person.
  • Ensure the support person is appropriate and has a helpful attitude towards the client.
  • Check conflict of interest.
  • Seek to avoid any situation where the client makes any admissions in the presence of the support person.
  • You may wish to consider asking the support person to sign a confidentiality agreement.

 

For further information
Legal Advice available between 2pm - 5pm weekdays

 

©IDRS, Intellectual Disability Rights Service 2C/199 Regent Street, Redfern, NSW 2016 Australia
Phone (02) 9318 0144
Fax (02) 9318 2887TollFree 1800 66 66 11 (within NSW)
CJSN 1300 665 908
URL www.idrs.org.au Email info@idrs.org.au

Disclaimer • Privacy Statement • Copyright
Updated September 21, 2006 Site Meter Design/Maintenance by Craig Andrews - PDCN
©2001-2005 Intellectual Disability Rights Service Inc. (IDRS)